how to prepare plaintiff for deposition06 Sep how to prepare plaintiff for deposition
To ensure the whole truth dont guess or add information you dont know or werent asked about. For example, you probably shouldnt review a police report, since those usually contain other witnesss statements. Some clients and cases require more than just a little discussion. However, perfect consistency might not be possible. Thank you again! Instruct your clients to assume the defense knows everything and that there are no secrets. This potentially case-altering event warrants thoughtful and intensive preparation. Phrases like, most of the time or more often than not become the plaintiffs friend in a deposition because they allow for some wiggle room. Webskill and thought in preparing your client for a deposition. Do not be intimidated by inaccurate records. The first is to obtain the information you will provide on your own behalf at trial, so that counsel is not surprised by anything and can adequately advise the insurer what you will say. Not true. You can make your client more comfortable by doing a practice deposition. Copyright Consider the sequence of your questions and make sure you are fully prepared. Totally grateful for all who helped get me behinds the scenes to get a fresh start. I refer all my friends to Ryan after my amazing experience with him and his firm! And I will reference my family and friends you and thank you so much. And do not be shy about this. You have to listen carefully to the question and then answer only that question. One aspect of trials is that they are, in part, morality plays about good and evil. It is far safer to testify in qualitative, rather than quantitative terms, such as a short time, or a short distance, rather than using precise figures. WebPrepare your client on procedural matters. If you have an injury causing low back pain, or anything which makes you uncomfortable during the deposition, let the other attorney know. He received his JD from the University of Wisconsin-Madison in 1998 and his PhD in American History from the University of Oregon in 2013. Usually we dont have these problems in Idaho depositions. If you dont have time to do a mock deposition, then look for videos your client could watch. As the defense lawyer, you can win your case if you disprove at least one legal element of the plaintiffs claim. Whether someone else was in their meetings with their lawyer. Not only is Mr Jean a tremendous attorney, he is a true gentlemen and has true compassion for his clients.I highly recommend Mr Jean and his team for any of your legal needs. The Plaintiffs Deposition Be Smart and Be Prepared In that situation there many things that happen. The lawyer wants to lock your client into a story so that the they can prepare for trial knowing what your client will say. WebThis practice note discusses how to prepare for and take an effective deposition of the plaintiff in an employment litigation, and includes sample questions. This group has gone above and beyond for my case. Ask that questions be clarified or rephrased if they dont understand them. This is a question even your own attorney may not be able to answer, unless he or she is familiar with opposing counsel. If you own a motorcycle, its important to know the Oklahoma motorcycle laws, so you can be sure youre riding legally. You dont know what to what to expect. You can review them with your client during your mock deposition. Only lawyers can make telling the truth so hard.. So Im pretty sure it was yellow.. Then, you can ask the client more specific questions about the collision, such as to each partys direction of travel, lane, speed, and visual obstructions (if any). This was my first time having to hire for this type of service and am honestly thrilled to have been referred to such a diligent, efficient and caring team. In an auto-collision case, this includes describing the force of the impact, the ways in which any body parts made contact with any portion of the inside of the vehicle, and any other specific movements of the plaintiffs body parts during the collision (such as the compression and twisting of a knee). To lock your client into a story. the truth) is, other than normal aches and pains, Ive never had a problem. If you think that an answer you will give may involve the attorney-client privilege, you may consult with your attorney about the privilege issue before answering. In a personal-injury case, this means reviewing all of the plaintiffs medical records, especially those which have been subpoenaed by the defense. But, seriously, dont be uncomfortable with the truth even when it is I dont know or I just dont remember right now. Often the truth of your memory is, I am not 100% sure but I think .. It is not your day in court. discussed how plaintiffs attorneys can prepare clients for a deposition in an auto accident personal injury case. Where would he have gotten that information, if not from you? The easiest way to deal with these records is to stick to your guns as to the facts and not try to explain records that you didnt create: I told Dr. Jones that I was wearing my seat belt, because I was. My first experience was that positive that I never thought about hiring another firm to handle my legal matter. Along those lines, advise your client to admit to prior and/or subsequent incidents or injuries (to the extent they exist) and to admit to whatever truth about which they are asked in deposition. Putting the photos and videos in front of the client can help bring her back to the time of the incident, eliciting memories about statements made at the scene of the incident, the identities of persons with whom she spoke, and other important details that may have washed away with time. Alex explained all my options and had the case settled in 6 months! Learn my secrets to preparing to take a witness's deposition. Dont try to hide or run away from troublesome facts, let your lawyer deal with them. Your attorney should have a meeting with you prior to the day of your deposition to prepare you and let you know of any areas of particular concern that may be specific to your case. So far from what I hear from other people about their cases Mr. Alex Jean is the best. Second, there are topics that regularly surprise clients. Notice I said review, not memorize. A deposition is not a memory test. Reviewing the complete medical file from all the providers will allow you to identify potential pressure points in the deposition concerning, for example, prior auto collisions, prior injuries, subsequent auto collision, and subsequent injuries. Ryan fought hard for me! Keep reading. Thus, the defense lawyer will use any fact she can, no matter how small or seemingly irrelevant, to try and show that an injured person is the bad guy and thus should lose. deposition is how prepared the defense attorney, Car Accident Deposition and What Happens Next, State Farm Car Accident Settlement Process, The Top 17 Mistakes to Avoid After a Car Accident. Theyre super friendly, super helpful and very very professional. If you change something important, like adding an injury, the defense attorney may want to depose you again on that subject alone, as he or she was not afforded the opportunity to do so at the first deposition. Your attorney has told you that your deposition has been set by the defendants attorney (make sure the date and time are good for you you should have been consulted about this before it was set, but if for some reason you need the date and time changed, the sooner you speak up the easier it will be). This article has been viewed 21,285 times. Had it not been for Mr. Wechsler I would have accumulated a lot of debt. It is important to spend time with your lawyer identifying concrete examples of the impact the injuries have had on your life. This guy is the real deal and is not less than THE BEST attorney I have ever had. Every case is unique. It is always better to correct these before the day of your deposition. .) and write down everything you and the attorneys say during your deposition. Thank you Long, Jean & Wechsler! If you can answer with yes or no, then you should do so. You will likely have been asked to provide written answer to questions prior to your deposition. I could not recommend this firm more!. You will have the chance to either learn why it is not an issue of concern, or to work on the issue so you are prepared to offer an honest non-harmful answer, Pingback: The Independent Medical Examination: Be Careful | Idaho Injury Lawyers Blog, Pingback: The Insurance Adjuster Wants A Recorded Statement: Tips For Doing It Right | Hepworth Holzer, During one of the most difficult times my family has ever gone through, the firm of Hepworth Holzer was our saving grace. Some are more long-winded than others and feel the need to explore seemingly irrelevant areas of questioning at length. THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT. Last Updated: October 21, 2021 These are more subtle things that can count in the settlement negotiations prior to trial. Additional to a very very good settlement amount, Lyle and his staff were a pleasure to work with. Whether the witness has testified before in a case. And they do this because it works to undermine your claim. Your lawyer will be there with you. And consistent with what you told the police for their report or the doctor who was treating you. I have had the pleasure of knowing Lyle Long for about 6 years now and consider him family. A witness might have stated that she saw your client run through a red light. Tips to Prepare for a Deposition The positioning of the plaintiffs body matters namely, whether your client braced for impact, gripped her hands on the steering wheel, swayed from side to side, or twisted in any way, for instance. You will also want to address those pressure points you have identified from the medical records. This is the essential difference between depositions and normal conversations among ordinary people. Do you come across as honest? If this is the type of attorney on your case, expect the deposition to take a little longer. Be nice and cordial back to the defense attorney, but keep repeating the following in your head once the deposition starts: Number 2 is particularly crucial. There will be no judge present. They made sure to stay in touch and keep me updated all throughout my case. by the author. From the beginning Lyle didnt take long at all to help me with my car wreck. Lyle was available to answer my questions and concerns at any given time, and would have no problem explaining any part of the process that I wasnt sure of. However, there is common ground that is covered by almost every bad guys lawyer during a deposition. After the deposition, if you realize that you made a mistake, tell your attorney so he or she can supplement your deposition in the manner allowed in your jurisdiction. Most cases dont go to trial, but one way to increase the odds of your case being one that does is doing a bad job at your deposition. For these reasons, the plaintiffs deposition should not be taken lightly. With respect to substantive preparation with your client, you will want to discuss three essential topics: (1) the incident itself; (2) your clients injuries and treatment; and (3) the before vs. after, or lifestyle changes, physical limitations, and general damages. There are dozens and dozens of such topics that some lawyers ask about. There are 9 references cited in this article, which can be found at the bottom of the page. However, the three reasons I just listed above still apply, and nothing beats getting your answers directly from the source. For example, if you had a prior injury to your body before the accident in this lawsuit, be prepared to talk about that. His office was in contact with me every time they had new information. I am forever grateful that he accepted my case. Dont play the silence game. There are not enough kind words to describe Alex Jean and his team. A good attorney will always take the time to prepare a client the way that lawyer believes the particular client should be prepared under the circumstances. Physical exertion category of work prior to accident(sedentary, light, medium, heavy or very heavy); Events on day of accident, in great detail; Conversations with adverse party and witnesses on the scene; Your role and responsibility for the accident or event, to show contributory negligence; Chronological medical history subsequent to day of accident, with treatment by each physician; Timetable for acute and chronic stages of your injury; Prior and subsequent accidents with injuries, if any, of any type (fall down, vehicle, workers compensation, etc. You do need to understand that in addition to getting your sworn answers on the record the opposing attorney or others who are there, will be evaluating you in other ways. However, the skirt should reach the knees and no clothing should be too tight. Three-Minute Legal Tips: Preparing for a Deposition Reviewing photographs and surveillance video footage, for example, can bring clarity to the client about details of the incident itself. SoDONT GUESS at anything. I think youll find that Alex is the right guy if youve been injured or have been in an accident. I was injured and hit by an uninsured, unlicensed driver, I know, what a surprise in south Florida! If you dont understand what is being asked, then politely request that the lawyer rephrase or repeat the question. Cozy up with your binder, a cup of tea, and some post-its you will want to mark, highlight, and tab any areas of concern, issues you want to discuss with your client before the deposition, and points worth emphasizing in the deposition. Rule 15.3 - Depositions, Ariz. R. Crim. P. 15.3 | Casetext Search Most plaintiffs attorneys can work with the truth about your physical condition to recover you a fair settlement or judgment. If you are handling a lumbar-spine injury case, creating a timeline will allow you to identify whether the plaintiff complained of low-back pain at the scene when interviewed by investigating law enforcement, at the emergency room, and with other healthcare providers with the progression of evaluation and treatment. Again, so long as these answers are truthful, these are acceptable and more favorable ways to frame the issue; it goes without saying that we should strictly avoid telling clients to make facts up if they are not true doing so is obviously unethical. A crane dropped on my car the week of Christmas. Counsel will cover at least the following topics in some detail: You should take another look at your medical records. Thats what I said, six months! Your job is not to confront the lawyer. It is much harder to lie or conceal something during a deposition, where follow-up questions can trap you should you choose to go that route. Be sure you heard and understood the question, Answer the Question, the Whole Question, and Nothing But the Question, The Plaintiffs Deposition: Tips For Witnesses In Injury Cases, The Independent Medical Examination: Be Careful | Idaho Injury Lawyers Blog, The Insurance Adjuster Wants A Recorded Statement: Tips For Doing It Right | Hepworth Holzer, Common Causes of Truck Accidents in Idaho and How to Avoid Them. It is just to answer the bad guys lawyers questions. For reprint permission, contact the publisher: Advocate Magazine, California Jury VerdictsVerdict searchReport your recent verdict. Sometimes attorneys ask questions that dont make sense. If a question can be answered yes, no, or I dont know, fairly and truthfully, then answer the question that way. Investing in your client is investing in your case. The witnesss social media accounts. Ive had some clients where a suit (which is unnecessary), but its really whatever you think will look professional, but also comfortable. WebAt deposition, prepare the plaintiff to focus on the most relatable of the facts. Defense counsel wants to give the plaintiffs answers to these questions to an accident reconstruction expert who will testify at trial that on the basis of the time and distance estimates by the plaintiff, the plaintiff was guilty of inattentive driving or lookout, negligent management and control, or some other violation of the rules of the road. If he doesnt say in his deposition that he looked over his shoulder before pulling into the other lane, then you can raise this omission at trial if he testifies on the witness stand that he looked over his shoulder. I got Into an accident 8/13/2021. For example, How long were you at the red light before you were hit from behind? What color was the defendants car? What was the substance you slipped on at the grocery store?. If you find yourself ready to pop off with your best estimate, instead simply tell him I would have to guess and I not comfortable with that. That is your answer and the attorney will have to move on. You can change any answer which you later realize is incorrect or incomplete. You might find out that he or she had left a bar or had been drinking alcohol at a friends house. Today, depositions are usually videotaped or the questions and answers are taken down by a court reporter. Do not tell the examiner where he or she may find the answer, either. The basic rule is DO NOT VOLUNTEER ANYTHING. If you think the defense attorney is trying to intimidate you, tell them you need to take a break, and then talk with your attorney about it. This article was co-authored by Clinton M. Sandvick, JD, PhD. Look no further for a beast of a lawyer Lyle is your guy! It is not lying, it normal. You want to come across as the sympathetic victim that the jury would want to compensate. If youre ever in need of a great legal team give them a call. It only happens if your injury claim cannot be settled and a lawsuit is filed. The court reporter is hired by the person taking the deposition to create a written transcript of everything that it said during the deposition word for word. If she admits that she didnt rely on the false information, then youve won your case. Ryan and Helen were very thorough and diligent with my case. The defense attorney cannot speak to you directly once you have an attorney, so this will be his or her only chance to directly question you before trial. WebDeposition Tips 1. Likewise, their [], How do I report an accident to State Farm? A deposition is an unfortunate time to talk about a knee injury that no doctor noted you had. Many people (and some lawyers) believe that this only applies to errors made by the court reporter. Its an act. A proactive approach to the plaintiffs deposition He was very helpful and I was literally able to reach out to him by phone or text any day and any time. Rule 15.3 - Depositions. "I'm trying to prepare to be a witness, and I'm undergoing a deposition sometime next month. In this situation, you could have a friend or family member read the complaint and then write out questions they have about what happened. A deposition is testimony given under oath in an informal setting. A proactive approach will give you and your client the strength to make this landmark moment go favorably. If you were to say that the color of the defendants car was black, when it was really canary yellow, that inaccuracy will call into question your entire memory of the accident. The video deposition can actually be your friend. Therefore, you should not say anything inconsistent with what is in the medical records, prior statements, or other utterings. They knocked it out of the park. My recovery was foremost on their minds.He fought for me relentlessly and got me what I truly deserved. This had. I feel like I was front and center all the way through. Generally speaking everything is fair game for questions. He gave me the assurance that everything was going to be okay. That is who will ask the questions. I would recommend any and every one I know who needs a Personal Injury attorney to use LJW Legal, because when they say they have your back and put you first, they actually mean it. Every step of the case, Mr Jean and Daniela kept me as well as my family involved in every detail. Not only because she is under oath, under the penalty of perjury, but because the credibility of the plaintiff in any case is sacrosanct. Instead, refresh their memory by reviewing relevant documents and other witness testimony. There is nothing wrong with refreshing your clients recollection of events; in fact, doing this through photos, videos, or other documents can be abundantly helpful in eliciting previously forgotten information. You may add to your answer by saying: To the best of my recollection . At the end, you can review your clients answers and talk about how they can improve their presentation. Tell him or her that you will need to shift/stand or whatever makes you feel comfortable at times during the deposition, and that he or she can keep going as long as you dont ask for a break. The more your Without doubt, the advice here is a bit generic. This practice note discusses how to prepare for and take an effective deposition of the plaintiff in an employment litigation, and includes sample questions. During your deposition prep meeting, first and foremost, you will want to explain the purpose of the deposition, so your client understands the gravity of the event. To uncover helpful information. Guessing most often happens when a Plaintiff is asked a question to which he or she would feel embarrassed not having an answer. Ten Things You Should Know Before Your Deposition in Your Similarly, in a case arising out of a slip-and-fall incident at a grocery store, have the client view the surveillance video footage before the deposition. Let your attorney know you want to read and sign! We had a great experience with Lyle and their team. It is not to be combative or argumentative. A deposition is a place where if you are not careful you can lose your case, but you cannot really win it there. During the deposition everything that is said, the questions and answers and comments, are being transcribed by a court reporter. How long were you unconscious for? Women can wear a skirt and a sweater. During your deposition, you can ask questions about what information the plaintiff relied on. The person/people you are suing have the right to be present at your deposition (though they wont participate directly). There are many reasons for a defense attorney to do this which may be entirely unrelated to your case. As lawyers, we can do our best to frame harmful or damaging aspects of our case. Preparing plaintiffs to speak their truth in deposition and at trial Spending time and energy on these topics during your preparation meeting will strengthen the deposition testimony and, ultimately, the defenses impressions of the plaintiff. . or I cannot be certain, but . The plaintiffs deposition is always a significant day in the prosecution of a personal injury case. He worked tirelessly on my case, which was a difficult one to begin with. Just be patient, responsive, and candid. His entire team (Daniela & Helen) was amazing. In three minutes, Jeff Feldman, professor of practice and co-director of the Appellate Advocacy Clinic, explains what to expect in the deposition process, who will be I am not advising that you withhold information in response to a question which has been asked. Unfortunately, this is my 2nd time hiring his firm. They treat you with respect, like an actual person and not just a case/number and thats why they stand out miles above the rest. This type of presentation will keep the focus on the substance of the testimony and the impact that the incident has had (and continues to have) on your clients life. Perhaps, before viewing the photos or videos, the plaintiff remembered the incident differently. But, if arguing has to occur, let your attorney do it. Im very thankful for all of his hard work and everyone at Long, Jean & Wechsler. This is the essential difference between depositions and normal conversations among ordinary people. Theres no rule that says you have to sit for your whole deposition (though it is courteous to do this if it doesnt cause you discomfort). For example, in an automobile accident lawsuit, you might depose the defendant. . Although it focuses on issues that commonly arise in employment discrimination and retaliation cases, many of the tips and steps discussed below transcend that context. Request to speak to your lawyer. Undoubtedly, the most important rule in a deposition is that the client must tell the truth. Often the clients real point (i.e. Tell The Truth:. Defense counsel will have two purposes for taking your deposition. For example, describe your injuries to the same parts of your body as you described them when you saw the doctor. There are some basic rules that apply to every deposition. Look at the written discovery and find gaps that opposing counsel will want to fill. Your responses to deposition questions need to be consistent with the answers in written discovery. Certainly, the central issues of your case are a prime area for questioning. If your deposition is not videotaped, there will be no record of the silence. At the end of your deposition, if you follow the rules Ive given you should feel tired and feel like you worked hard. WebA son of actor and former Gov. As amended through December 8, 2022. But the rules allow for deposition questions to stray into nearly unlimited topics as long as the answers are reasonably calculated to lead to admissible evidence.. Sometimes, its hard to know what a lawyer will ask. Very pleasant and kept me up to date every step of the way during my case. For example, if you are sued for a traffic accident, the lawyer might ask: What color was the light when you went through the intersection? Your first instinct might be to ramble: I think it was yellow. Thats why you hired him or her. Answer the question you have been asked and then shut up. You may identify advantageous information in the clients medical-intake forms or pain diagrams or a doctors handwritten chart notes that might not make its way into a physicians final report. Some insurance company attorney have a large caseload, and they may not know the ins and outs of your case until your deposition. Your job at the deposition is just to answer the questions. At a minimum, you should review your Complaint (the document your attorney prepared to kick off the lawsuit), your interrogatory answers (written answers to questions submitted by the defense attorney which you signed under oath), and the accident report, if there was one. The deposition is based on your knowledge and memory alone, not your attorneys. The process can, quite frankly, be annoying. The Basics of Being Prepared: 1. For example, if you were in a car crash, the lawyer will have many questions about what you did before you got into your car and while you were driving. Try to schedule your mock deposition for the day before the actual deposition. The Plaintiffs Deposition Be Smart and Be Prepared. He then instructed me what to do further. Alexis Gamliel is a trial attorney at AlderLaw, focusing her practice on catastrophic personal injury and wrongful death cases, as well as employment matters. For example, if the lawsuit is a breach of contract case, then you will want to ask questions about (1) the negotiation process, (2) the contract, (3) the witness breaking the contract. Counsel will purposely avoid questions you might want him or her to ask which you think would enhance your claim. It has been a huge relief to know I am taken care of and in good hands. If the lawyer asks you a question, answer it. There is nothing wrong with simply stating, I do not recall.. LJW legal team is by far the one you want to represent you for any personal injury case you have. Considering the fact my accident occurred during the holiday season, Lyle and his paralegal, Helen, ensured that I received treatment the same day, got a rental, and even settled my case in less than 6 months.They were extremely polite, communicative, and on top of everything. One standard defense lawyer tactics is to try to get you to make a mistake by asking a question in absolute terms, i.e., Tell me everything, Thats all the problems youve had?, etc. He was very prompt with his responses and very helpful when we first touched base. The plaintiffs deposition is a special time in the litigation process because its where the rubber hits the road where the case comes to life. Similarly, on the other side of the spectrum, you may also find damaging information in those sources, and it is much better to frontload learning about this before you have a deposition prep meeting with your client and, of course, before the time of the deposition. I had the pleasure of being represented by Lyle Long. Some disputes are obviously he said, she said disputes where two people have opposing memories of what happened. At the end of the deposition, the court reporter will ask your attorney if you want to read and sign your deposition or waive that right. For checklists and templates on preparing for and taking depositions, see Deposing Plaintiffs in Employment Litigation Checklist and Deposition Questions (Discrimination, Harassment, or Retaliation) (Defendant to Plaintiff).
No Comments